Like the other pages at this website, this page is a "work in progress." Information is added as it is discovered and/or contributed. if you have info or artifacts that enhance this page, please use the Webmaster link in the footer of this page.

The following chronology of Darrtown doctors was assembled from a narrative found in the 1882 publication titled A History and Biographical Cyclopedia of Butler County, Ohio."  The Milford Township section, with information about the three communities of Darrtown, Collinsville, and Somerville, appears on pages 562-574.

1827 - Dr. Yeaman arrived from Hamilton and remained two or three years, before moving to Crawfordsville, Indiana.


1832 - Dr. Cruikshank arrived from Cheviot, Ohio and remained seven or eight years, before selling his practice to Dr. Mack.


1833 - Dr. Wilson arrived from New England and remained for five years, before moving to Rossville, Indiana.


1840 - Dr. Wyman arrived from New York. Dr. Wyman introduced the common domestic willow at Darrtown, around 1845.


1840 (circa) - Dr. Mack purchased Dr. Cruikshank’s practice. Dr. Mack continued his practice at Darrtown, until his death (circa mid-1870s).


Research background: 

In September 2014, Kim Johnson contributed the photo (below) of Dr. Twitchell and the news article (BELOW), which Kim discovered within Ancestry.com records. The date of the article's first appearance is unknown. If the handwriting on the right panel of the image is accurate, then it links the image to the story below.

Given the years associated with Dr. Twitchell's life span and other life-markers reported below, it appears that Dr. Twitchell served Darrtown and vicinity in the late 1870s and/or early 1880s. It seems that the person who wrote the article was not familiar with Darrtown, as he referred to the village of Darrtown as a "small city." Also, Dr. Twitchell is cited as the local physician that directed the exhuming of a murder victim's body during the investigation of the 1884 Schneider murder case.

"HERBERT EUGENE TWITCHELL was born in Chatfield, Minnesota, March 27, 1855 and was the first white child native to the village.

With his sisters Edna, Carpie and Martha (the only brother died in infancy) he was educated, first in the schools of Chatfield, attending Chatfield Academy in its short, but honorable, span.  He then went to Normal School at Winona, Minnesota - teaching school, for a time afterward, in the Chatfield public schools.

His formal medical training he received in the Louisville Medical College, where he graduated in 1877, after having received a scholarship.  He began the practice of medicine in the small city of Darrtown,Ohio, and in 1882 received postgraduate training at the University of Cincinnati.

In 1885 he took the hospital course at the Cincinnati General Hospital and, on April 18, 1886, he opened an office at Hamilton,Ohio where he practiced his profession, until a few years before his death.

In 1878, he was married Carrie A. Spencer of Louisville, and of this union one child was born, Anna Spencer Twitchell, who is now Mrs. Dwight Person of Los Angeles, California, who gained some prominence as a writer of verse for our leading periodicals.  She was a member of the Poetry Society of America, and has published one volume of verse, W...STAR AND GRASS, a copy of which is in the Chartield Library. Carrie Spencer Twitchell died May 14, 1885.

The late president McKinley appointed Dr. Twitchell one of the surgeons of the First Ohio Volunteer Infantry, with the rank of Captain, during the Spanish American War and he served until the end of the war in 1898.

In October, 1915, Dr. Twichell was named Surgeon of the Central Branch of the National Military home in Dayton, but did not accept the position. Dr. Twitchell was a member of the Sons of The Revolution and of the Military Order of the LO...Legion of the U.S.A. which consists of sons of officers of the Army of the United States."

The historic sketch of Herbert Eugene Twitchell that appears at the right was discovered on March 25, 2019, during an Internet search.


The illustrated book from which this item was copied is titled "Biographical and HIstorical Sketches - A Narrative of Hamilton and Its Residents - from 1792 to 1896." The author is Stephen D. Cone.


It seems noteworthy to report that the book is dedicated to Herbert E. Twitchell.


More info about Dr. Twitchell...

collection of excerpts from Mr. Miller's diaries, spanning the years 1900 - 1937, appears at the L.A. Diaries.


Dr. Herbert E. Twitchell


THREE SOURCES corroborate that Dr. Andrew Wilkie was a physician for many who lived in and around Darrtown during the early 20th century.

Those resources include:

   (1) personal recollections,

   (2) the L. A. Miller Diaries, and

   (3) three U. S. census reports.

No image available

There are some individuals still living (2014) who recall Dr. Wilkie from their personal memories or they recall older relatives who spoke of him. For example:

          Dale Bufler recalls that Dr. Wilkie had an office (and possibly a residence) on the east side of Main Street, between Apple and North Streets.

          Ron Wiley and Fred Lindley, among others, recall a "Gladys Wilkie" farm that was the second place west of Darrtown, on the north side of Schollenbarger Road (see map below).

          Charley Teckman, in two email messages (posted below) shared his recollections of Doctor Wilkie.

In 2012, the Darrtown.com webmaster posted a request for people to submit memories of George Kolb. In response, Charles Teckman shared his recollection of Mr. Kolb. During the exchange of information about George Kolb, Charley included information about TWO DARRTOWN MEN that he remembered as Dr. Wilkie (see Charley's 2012 message posted below).

In 2014, when asked to clarify his 2012 comments about the two men named Dr. Wilkie, Charley shared more of his memories (see Charley's 2014 message posted below).

2012 email message

from Charles Teckman




The George Kolb farm, as I understand it was the next farm East of your grandfather.  It was in the 1940’s owned by Joe Dietrich. I think I am right.


Dr. Wilkie came to Darrtown from the State of Washington.  Somehow Belle Wilkie Miller, wife of Ernie Miller,  was a niece of Dr. Wilkie.  She was the daughter of another Dr. Wilkie, in Darrtown, who delivered me as a baby in 1929.  He lived just four houses  South of us on the East side of 177 between Schmidts on the South and Laughlins on the North. The property today is a lot full of weeds.


Dr. Wilkie became a friend of Miss Harris who lived alone, after her parents died on the farm across the road (north) side of the road from your grandparents.  They married and lived together on the farm, which of course was her property.


Note, we are talking about two different Dr. Wilkie’s.  One who spent his life in Darrtown.  I remember him when I was a boy,  and the second who came to Darrtown when he was an older man , after living and practicing medicine in Washington state.



2014 email message

from Charles Teckman




The info I gave you is correct as I remember it.


The first Dr. Wilkie, who practiced in Darrtown and delivered me in 1929, was the father of Bell Wilkie Miller, and he died about early 1940s.


The second Dr. Wilkie who married Miss Harris came to Darrtown, after 1950, from Seattle , Washington to live with his niece Bell Miller, wife of Ernie Miller.


I think Ernie and Bell met when she worked the Darrtown telephone company for Ernie’s father L.A. Miller whom you know from the diary.



Webmaster Note:


The map at the right illustrates the information

in Charley Teckman's email messages (above).


Also, note that he location of Dr. Wilkie's office was confirmed by Dale Bufler's comment (see "1. Personal recollections" above).

(1) Personal recollections corroborate "Doc" Wilkie

(2) L.A. Miller diaries corroborate "Doc" Wilkie

Dr. Wilkie is mentioned numerous times in the L. A. Miller diaries, which span the years between 1900 and 1937. In his diaries, Mr. Lewis A. Miller writes about interacting with Dr. Wilkie on his own accord and, more specifically, L. A. Miller mentions Dr. Wilkie, in reference to Bell, Dr. Wilkie's daughter. In 1916, Bell Wilkie married Ernie Miller, who was the son of Mr. L. A. Miller. Click the following link to access the Miller diaries.

(3) U.S. Census reports corroborate "Doc" Wilkie

The 1910 census report (see image below) displays the name "Andrew B. Wilkie" on the same page as other persons who are known to have lived in or near Darrtown. Hence, it seems reasonable to conclude that Dr. Andrew Wilkie was a resident of Darrtown and/or vicinity.

These images below show details from the 1910 census report for the Andrew B. Wilkie family.

The 1920 census report provides similar information, except that in 1920, only Andrew and Mary are listed (presumably Bell had move out by that time; the L. A. Miller diaries show that Bell and Ernie Miller married June 15, 1916).

The 1930 census report shows similar information and includes the fact that a grandson, William Miller (age 12) was, at that time, living with Andrew and Mary. William Moulton Miller was the son of Bell and Ernie Miller.

We have evidence of Dr. Twitchell serving the Darrtown community in the year 1884, as he is named as the physician who directed the exhumation of a murdered widow. (The citation is found on page six of the book titled "Where's Your Mother, George?") See "Murder 1884" in the list of topics in this History section.